I’ll be direct with you: the playing field between independent optometry and corporate optical is not level. And pretending otherwise isn’t doing any of us any favors.
Corporate groups and private equity-backed practices have advantages that are structural, not accidental. They negotiate from a position of volume. They have centralized purchasing, dedicated operations teams, and infrastructure built specifically to drive down costs and drive up margins. They didn’t build those advantages by working harder than you — they built them by operating at a scale most independent practices can’t match alone.
But here’s what I’ve learned after 20+ years building a 9-doctor, 5-location independent practice: scale isn’t the only path to competitive advantage. And independent ODs who understand that are quietly closing the gap.
What Corporate Gets That Most Independents Don’t
The core advantage corporate groups hold comes down to three things: purchasing power, operational efficiency, and systems.
Purchasing power means they’re paying less for the same frames and lenses you’re buying. Their volume gives them leverage at the negotiating table that a single-location practice simply doesn’t have. The result shows up directly in COGS — and the national average for independent practices, between 27% and 35%, reflects it. This is not a “menu buying group” it is a GPO that continually negotiates and does not create a menu you pick from but an aggressive all in this together model.
Operational efficiency means their staff isn’t spending hours managing frame boards, reconciling vendor invoices, or manually tracking inventory. Those systems are built and automated at the corporate level. In most independent practices, that burden still falls on the owner and the team.
Systems means they’re not reinventing the wheel with every new hire, every vendor change, or every operational decision. There’s a playbook. Independent ODs, by and large, are writing their own — which takes time and costs money.
None of this means corporate wins by default. It means independent practices need to be intentional about closing those gaps rather than hoping goodwill and clinical excellence alone carry the day.
How Independents Are Leveling the Playing Field
The most effective thing an independent OD can do is stop operating in isolation. The economics of independence improve dramatically when you’re part of a network that negotiates collectively.
A well-structured group purchasing organization gives independent practices access to the same pricing leverage that corporate groups take for granted — without surrendering autonomy, paying membership fees, or being told which products to use. The right GPO isn’t a compromise on independence. It’s what makes independence financially sustainable.
Beyond pricing, the operational gap closes when you adopt the right systems. Moving from a traditional frame board model — where you front the inventory cost and carry all the risk — to a no-cost consignment approach immediately frees up capital and reduces overhead. Implementing a streamlined lens sales model removes complexity from your staff’s workflow and makes training faster and more consistent. These aren’t corporate-only advantages. They’re available to any practice willing to rethink how their optical operates.
Independence Is Worth Protecting — But It Has to Be Profitable
I founded Partners in Profit because I believed independent optometry was worth fighting for. Not out of sentiment, but because independent practices deliver something corporate groups structurally cannot: genuine, patient-centered care, rooted in the community, driven by a doctor who has real skin in the game.
But independence without profitability isn’t sustainable. And the practices that will still be thriving independent in ten years are the ones that treat their business with the same rigor they bring to their clinical care.
The gap between independent and corporate is real. It’s also closeable. The tools exist — the question is whether you’re using them.
Innovate and Profit with Us!
Join the ranks of thriving optometry practices.
Learn more about our innovative frame and lens modeling program by speaking with one of our dedicated team members.